Read the article assigned and located in the E-Reserves. Pay particular attention to the references these authors make to the works of others. Every citation within this article is essentially a head nod to other authors who have written about the same or similar topics. Were they all in the same room, you could imagine the authors of this article pointing to or calling out those other authors while speaking. This is what we mean when we refer to research and writing as one big conversation, with all of the participants listening and responding to one another. Please note: You only need to read and analyze the assigned e-reserves article. You do not need to locate the articles cited within it.

In a discussion post, point to an example from this article and explain how the authors do one of the following:

refer to another work in order to give legitimacy to their own point;
refer to another work in order to build upon the ideas of others; or
refer to another work in order to challenge that work.
If you select “refer to another work in order to give legitimacy to their own point,” first describe what the authors’ point is, then describe how the cited article supports that point.

If you select “refer to another work in order to build upon the ideas of others,” first describe what the ideas are, then describe how the authors build upon those ideas.

If you select “refer to another work in order to challenge that work”, first describe what is being challenged, then describe how the authors are challenging the cited work.

Then, give an example from your own life in which you rely upon the work of others to complete a task or accomplish a goal. (This example might be from your workplace, community, or academic life.)

Scoring

9-10 points: Post identifies examples from both the text and the students life. Fully explains the significance of these examples.

6-8 points: Post identifies examples, but fails to adequately describe/discuss those examples within the stated context.

0-5 points: Post does not identify an example from the text or an example from the students life.